Modern Vectors of Economic Oppression Carceral Systems
Help Us Test and Refine Our Curriculum
Welcome to our 15-module series exploring the historic basis of the racial wealth gap as a vehicle for understanding the need for repair.
Watch the video below, briefly explore our curriculum, then take our survey and let us know what you think. Thank you!
"For the (racial wealth) gap to be closed, America must undergo a vast social transformation produced by the adoption of bold national policies, policies that will forge a way forward by addressing, finally, the long-standing consequences of slavery, the Jim Crow years that followed, and ongoing racism and discrimination that exist in our society today."
W. Darity, D. Hamilton, M. Paul, A Aja, A. Price, A. Moore, and C. Chiopris
Learn about criminal justice policy affects the racial wealth gap
Summary
Origins of Modern-Day Policing
The origins of our modern-day police mentality can be traced back to the “Slave Patrol”. The earliest formal slave patrol was created in the Carolinas in the early 1700s, with the following mission: to establish a system of terror in response to slave uprisings with the capacity to pursue, apprehend, and return runaway slaves to their owners, including the use of excessive force to control and produce desired slave behavior. Slave Patrols allowed forcible entry into any home solely based on suspicions of protecting runaway slaves. Slave Patrols continued until the end of the Civil War and the passage of the 13th Amendment.
Following the Civil War, during the Reconstruction Period, slave patrols were replaced by militia-style groups who were empowered to control and deny access to equal rights to freed slaves that looked to join the workforce and integrate with society. Their work included the enforcement of Black Codes, strict local and state laws that regulated and restricted access to labor, wages, voting rights, and general freedoms for formerly enslaved people.
In 1868, ratification of the 14th Amendment technically granted equal protections by laws of Constitutional rights to African Americans – essentially meant to abolish Black Codes. Shortly after the abolishment of Black Codes, Jim Crow Laws, and state and local statutes that legalized racial segregation were enacted. Jim Crow laws looked to vanquish all protected rights of African Americans. By the 1900s, local municipalities began to construct police departments to enforce local laws in areas of the East Coast and Mid-West, including Jim Crow Laws. Local municipalities leaned on police to enforce and exert excessive brutality on African Americans who violated any Jim Crow law. Jim Crow Laws continued through the end of the 1960s.
Since then, African American communities have continued to be under surveillance and targeted by police, including, but not limited to, the era of War on Drugs and mass incarceration.
Sources:
Personal Narratives
"The first time I fit the description of a suspect I was ten. And the more I was stopped for conversations with police, the more I began to make adjustments in my life.
I had to learn not to stand outside the house with nondescript cups, or ride four-deep to the club. Some of our friends like to keep all the registration papers in their glove box ultra-updated. Others get nervous about how many people in their backseats are wearing ball caps.
For as long as the term racial profiling has been around, fools have been denying the phenomenon exists. But I contend every black man in America, at some point, will be racially profiled or harassed by the police. It's a part of the DNA of our experience in the United States.
One morning last spring while I was parking my car at the BART train station, a police officer looked at me and ran my license plate. He entered a false number, and my Oldsmobile Royale Brougham 88 came back as a stolen Honda. So now I'm a car thief. My friend, Elmer(ph), and I weren't prepared for what happened next.
ELMER: Our conversation was interrupted very rudely and abruptly.
Mr. HOWELL: I mean, just how to - what happened.
ELMER: In the distant background I hear the voice of a police officer saying, everybody move aside. And I turned around to see the barrel of this officer's handgun staring me down, face to face. And he tells me to step back and stand on the concrete.
He said, you know, brothers like you, I know how you all get down. You all be in the street, you all steal cars. You're like, you know, he's not talking to us like, you know, like citizens, you know. He's talking to us like we're convicted criminals that he's delivering to Massachusetts for multiple murders..."
Anyi Howell
Source:
Timeline of Criminal Justice Disparities
Metrics: The Economic Impact of Criminal Justice Discrimination on the Racial Wealth Gap
Across U.S. history, the criminal justice system has not simply mirrored economic exclusion—it has generated it, functioning as a sustained extractor of Black wealth. From slavery to mass incarceration, law enforcement systems have criminalized Black existence to justify forced labor, economic displacement, and intergenerational poverty. Early mechanisms like slave patrols and the convict leasing system legally funneled Black labor into state and corporate profit structures, converting freedom into debt. During the Jim Crow era, racial terror tactics like lynchings and police violence worked hand-in-hand with economic sabotage, pushing Black families off land, denying them business opportunities, and displacing wealth geographically. Civil Rights-era repression, including COINTELPRO surveillance, actively dismantled community-led economic initiatives and suppressed the potential for collective advancement. The War on Drugs and mandatory minimums escalated this extractive logic into modern carceral capitalism, targeting Black neighborhoods with militarized policing, shattering household structures, and criminalizing survival.
In the contemporary era, the economic violence of the justice system operates through subtler yet equally devastating channels: algorithmic bias, inflated bail costs, criminal record stigma, and municipal revenue models that exploit Black residents via fines and fees. Police brutality now brings not only trauma but direct community-level asset depletion through reduced property values and increased insurance rates. At each stage, wealth is not only denied—it is taken, redistributed upward, or converted into state and corporate profit. Estimates show the cumulative impact of criminal justice discrimination contributes 10–20% of the racial wealth gap in the U.S., a staggering figure when paired with centuries of unpaid labor and ongoing extraction mechanisms. This is not merely history—it is a live economy of exclusion, engineered through legislation, upheld by judicial precedent, and legitimized through narratives of criminality that mask structural theft.
Aggregate Estimate:
Criminal justice discrimination accounts for 10–20% of the racial wealth gap, driven by labor theft, asset stripping, and institutionalized exclusion.
Methods of Criminal Justice Discrimination
Algorithmic & Digital Justice Bias
New forms of discrimination now appear in data systems and technology that claim to be objective. Predictive policing algorithms, facial recognition tools, and sentencing risk assessments often over-target Black people because they’re trained on biased historical data. These systems replicate the very patterns of exclusion they were meant to eliminate—amplifying arrest rates, reinforcing stereotypes, and embedding racial inequity into “smart” justice.
Further Research
Biased Jury Selection
Despite constitutional protections, Black citizens remain systematically underrepresented on juries and disproportionately excluded through peremptory challenges. This racial bias in jury pools undermines the concept of “a jury of one’s peers,” resulting in harsher sentencing and more frequent convictions for Black defendants. The exclusion also denies Black communities participation in one of democracy’s core civic processes.
Broken Windows & Petty Offense Policing
Policies that emphasize punishment for minor offenses—such as “Broken Windows” policing—disproportionately target Black neighborhoods, echoing post-Reconstruction “Black Codes.” By criminalizing poverty and everyday behavior, these policies entangle people in cycles of fines, arrests, and debt that drain community wealth and reinforce racial stereotypes about crime.
Edward Banfield: The racist, classist origins of broken windows policing.
Collateral Consequences
After incarceration, Black individuals face lasting penalties that extend far beyond their sentence. These include exclusion from employment, housing, voting, federal student aid, and professional licensing. Such restrictions perpetuate economic insecurity, reduce homeownership and savings, and prevent generational wealth transfer—creating an enduring underclass defined by past conviction rather than future potential.
Further Research
How “Collateral Consequences” Keep People Trapped in the Legal System | Vera Institute
Collateral Consequences and the Enduring Nature of Punishment | Brennan Center for Justice
Disproportionate Police Contact & Investigations
Black people experience more frequent stops, searches, and surveillance than any other racial group, even when crime rates are equal or lower. Targeted policing in Black neighborhoods increases the likelihood of arrest and prosecution, creating cumulative disadvantage that ripples across employment, credit access, and family stability.
CPE-WhitePaper-Compounding-Disparities.pdf
Racial Disparities in Law Enforcement Stops - Public Policy Institute of California
Parole & Probation Bias
Racial bias continues after incarceration through unequal treatment in parole and probation decisions. Black individuals are more likely to be denied parole, given stricter conditions, or re-incarcerated for minor infractions compared to white counterparts. This leads to longer confinement, reduced employment opportunities, and diminished family income.
Racial Disparities and Delays in Parole System Highlighted in New Report - Davis Vanguard
Pretrial Incarceration & Bail Disparities
Because bail systems are tied to income, Black defendants—who statistically hold less wealth—are more likely to remain in jail before trial. Judges also set higher bail amounts for Black defendants, even when controlling for risk factors. Pretrial detention increases the odds of conviction, job loss, and family disruption, fueling intergenerational poverty.
Further Research
Racial Bias in Exoneration
Black defendants are seven times more likely to be wrongfully convicted of serious crimes than white defendants and spend longer behind bars before exoneration. The financial and psychological toll—lost income, housing, and community standing—rarely receives compensation. These injustices illustrate how race shapes even post-conviction “corrections” in the justice system.
Further Research
Race and Exonerations: Why Black Defendants Are More Likely To Be Wrongfully Convicted
Sentencing Disparities
Black defendants face disproportionately severe sentencing outcomes. Prosecutors are more likely to seek charges carrying mandatory minimums or habitual offender penalties, while underfunded public defense systems limit access to fair representation. The result is longer incarceration, reduced lifetime earnings, and widened racial wealth gaps.
Further Research:
One in Five: Racial Disparity in Imprisonment — Causes and Remedies – The Sentencing Project
Racial Disparities in Sentencing: Stories, Data, and Solutions for Justice Reform - clutch.
Stop, Question, and Frisk Policies
Stop-and-frisk policing disproportionately targets Black male residents in urban, low-income areas. Though marketed as a crime deterrent, these policies often yield minimal evidence recovery while inflicting deep community distrust and criminalizing normal behavior. They also carry long-term financial consequences through fines, lost wages, and job barriers.
Further Reading:
What is Stop-and-Frisk? | Vera Institute
The Dangers of Stop-and-Frisk: Key Concerns and Issues with Police Policies - clutch.
Unequal Treatment of Black Law Enforcement Officers
Black officers often experience discrimination within police departments, facing fewer promotions, more discipline, and less peer support. Their presence does not eliminate systemic bias, as institutional culture continues to center whiteness. This internal inequity reinforces racial hierarchies and limits opportunities for reform from within the system.
Further Research:
Black in Blue: African-American Police Officers and Racism | Office of Justice Programs
How Black Police Officers Combat Systemic Racism at Work
War on Drugs
The War on Drugs fueled one of the most racially unequal systems of punishment in U.S. history. Black people are more likely to be searched, arrested, and imprisoned for drug offenses, even though usage rates are similar across races. This policy’s economic fallout—through incarceration, job loss, and community destabilization—continues to widen the racial wealth gap.
Further Research:
Race, Mass Incarceration, and the Disastrous War on Drugs | Brennan Center for Justice
Nixon Adviser Admits War on Drugs Was Designed to Criminalize Black People
Additional Reading and Viewing Materials
Film/Video
"The New Jim Crow" - Author Michelle Alexander, George E. Kent Lecture 2013
Slavery to Mass Incarceration - EJI
Mass Incarceration & Rebuilding the Black Community | Jondhi Harrell | TEDxWilliamPennCharterSchool
We need to talk about an injustice | Bryan Stevenson
Bryan Stevenson: There’s a Direct Line From Lynching to George Floyd | Amanpour and Company
Policing the Black Man: A Conversation with Angela J. Davis and Sherrilyn Ifill - YouTube
Articles
Report to the United Nations on Racial Disparities in the U.S. Criminal Justice System
The War on Marijuana in Black and White (Edwards, Bunting, Garcia)
“Give Us Free”: Addressing Racial Disparities in Bail Determinations (C.E. Jones)
NAACP | Criminal Justice Fact Sheet
[d] The Color of Justice: Racial and Ethnic Disparity in State Prisons (A. Nellis)
Illegal Racial Discrimination in Jury Selection (eji.org)
Black and Blue: What Say You? | Medium
The History Of Policing In The United States, Part 1 | Police Studies Online |
Rollback of Carceral System Reform Spurs Rikers Island Crisis (theintercept.com)
The History of Policing in the United States, Part 2 | Police Studies Online
Angola - Louisiana State Penitentiary - Wikipedia
The Company Store and the Literally Captive Market: Consumer Law in Prisons and Jails
What 'Stop-and-Frisk' really means | Prison Policy Initiative
How race impacts who is detained pretrial | Prison Policy Initiative
Assessing Racial Disparities in Parole Release on JSTOR
Books
The New Jim Crow (M. Alexander)
Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption (B. Stevenson)
From the War on Poverty to the War on Crime: The Making of Mass Incarceration in America (E. Hinton)
No Equal Justice: Race and Class in the American Criminal Justice System (D. Cole)
Locking Up Our Own: Crime and Punishment in Black America (J. Foreman Jr.)
Questions for Research and Reflection
✊🏿 FOR BLACK PEOPLE
Surveillance, Survival, and Systemic Punishment
-
What has been your family's historic relationship to police, jails, or prisons? Were ancestors ever criminalized for survival — loitering, walking, resisting, reading?
-
Were you taught to fear police, avoid them, or submit to survive? Who taught you that?
-
Have you or your loved ones been stopped, searched, harassed, or harmed by police for existing in public space?
-
How often have you been followed in stores, surveilled on public transit, or confronted with racial suspicion?
-
Have you or your community faced pretextual stops, gang database inclusion, school policing, or parole traps?
-
How has incarceration — even of one person — affected your family’s economic stability, housing, mental health, or access to jobs?
-
How did you experience the uprisings of 2020 — as grief, movement, exhaustion, all of the above?
-
Has anyone in your family been denied bail, overcharged, or pressured into a plea deal? What was the impact?
-
What would actual justice look like for your community — not symbolic reforms, but full abolition, land return, reparations?
⚪ FOR WHITE PEOPLE
Policed Privilege, Carceral Immunity, and Structural Denial
-
Were you taught that police were there to help you? Did that belief ever change — or was it affirmed by experience?
-
Have you ever broken a law but not been arrested? Who or what protected you?
-
Did you grow up in a neighborhood where police were stationed as protectors — or where they were largely absent?
-
Were your schools policed? Were infractions handled with suspension, tickets, or “second chances”?
-
Do you know someone who got probation for something that sent someone else to prison? What role did race play?
-
Have you ever thought about who benefits from mass incarceration — financially, politically, or psychologically?
-
Do you believe police violence is about a few “bad apples,” or a system that was designed to patrol, not protect?
-
Has your family ever used lawyers, bail money, or social capital to get out of trouble? Could everyone else?
-
Are you willing to divest from police-based models of safety — even if it means disrupting your own sense of order?
🌎 FOR ALL PEOPLE
Cages, Courts, and the Myth of Justice
-
What were you taught about police, crime, and justice growing up — and who was cast as criminal?
-
What does “public safety” mean to you — and who gets protected by it? Who gets punished in its name?
-
Have you ever had to change your appearance, voice, or behavior out of fear of police retaliation?
-
Do you know someone who has been incarcerated? How did the legal process affect them, financially and emotionally?
-
What were their bail conditions, court fees, or parole requirements? Were they manageable — or designed for failure?
-
How does the media you consumed shape your assumptions about guilt, innocence, and danger?
-
Have you or your community been impacted by gang injunctions, curfews, drug policing, or algorithmic surveillance?
-
What’s the relationship between the carceral system and other systems: housing, schools, mental health, foster care, immigration, and employment?
-
If police and prisons didn’t exist, what would accountability and repair look like — for harm, for trauma, for the conditions that produced them?
Reckoning with an Unjust Past: a Spoken Word Series by Veronica Wylie